Permanent Public Access Secured for Burt Dam Fishery

A protracted disagreement regarding public entry to a renowned fishing location has reached a positive conclusion. What began with the appearance of 'No Trespassing' signs, sparking concerns among anglers and local authorities, has culminated in a formal agreement. This resolution not only restores confidence for the fishing community but also underlines the importance of collaboration in preserving cherished natural resources and supporting regional commerce. The outcome means that both recreational enthusiasts and the surrounding businesses, which rely on the influx of visitors, can look forward to uninterrupted seasons ahead.

Public Access to Burt Dam Fishery Reinstated After Resolution of Land Dispute

In a significant development for the angling community, the Town of Newfane announced on August 14 that permanent public access to the prized fishing grounds below Burt Dam on Eighteen Mile Creek has been officially secured. This resolves a year-long dispute that began in 2025 when 'No Trespassing' signs emerged along the traditional pathway leading to the popular fishery, creating uncertainty for anglers.

The agreement, formalized through a permanent public access easement recorded with the Niagara County Clerk’s Office, guarantees that the existing trail on the east side of Eighteen Mile Creek will remain open for public use. This means anglers can once again enjoy uninterrupted access to the abundant salmon, steelhead, and brown trout that migrate into the creek from Lake Ontario, especially during the crucial fall, winter, and spring seasons.

Previously, the conflict arose not only from the unexpected signage but also from questions concerning the Town of Newfane’s long-established management practices, including fees and an ATV shuttle service. The town, which at one point considered legal avenues like adverse possession and eminent domain to preserve access, ultimately opted for a cooperative approach. By reviewing property records, they identified the legal landowner and engaged in direct negotiations to achieve an amicable solution.

This collaborative effort led to the Newfane Town Board’s approval of the agreement on July 22, 2026, followed by its official recording on August 13. The permanent easement ensures that public access is no longer subject to informal understandings or potential property line disputes, solidifying the future of this vital recreational site.

The Burt Dam fishery is a considerable asset for Western New York, attracting anglers from various regions. Their activities contribute significantly to the local economy, benefiting bait shops, tackle suppliers, restaurants, gas stations, and other businesses in Newfane, Burt, and Olcott. The town acknowledged this positive economic impact in its announcement, highlighting the broader benefits of resolving the access issue.

With this resolution, anglers can now redirect their focus from property debates back to the nuances of fishing—debating fish species, optimal lures, and the best spots for a prize catch. The certainty of access allows them to fully immerse themselves in the sport they love.

This resolution underscores the critical role of community engagement and negotiation in safeguarding public resources. It serves as a positive example of how local authorities and private landowners can collaborate to maintain access to natural areas, benefiting both recreational users and the economic well-being of the surrounding communities. This outcome ensures that future generations of anglers can continue to enjoy the rich fishing heritage of Eighteen Mile Creek without impediment.